Obama, the Armenian Genocide & the Photographic Record

2486681731_23e7d7b401Photo of Armenian Genocide survivors, AGBU Archive

Tomorrow is April 24, the day Armenians around the world commemorate the Armenian Genocide of 1915 perpetrated by the Young Turk government in the twilight years of the Ottoman Empire. This year, like every year, Armenian Americans will be waiting to hear the US President use the “G” word to describe the events of the period.

This may be the year and the expectations are high since President Barack Obama has been more adamant about his support for Armenian Genocide recognition than any president in history [here is a 24 page PDF (1.8MB) outlining Obama’s support through the years].

While news pundits and denialists try to make the Armenian Genocide issue about Turkey or Armenia or something to be left to historians, the reality is that most Armenian Americans simply want their government to recognize the historical events as fact, which will, hopefully, put a stop to the Genocide denial industry of hate funded by Turkey and propagated in the US through paid lobbyists.

Here’s to hoping that change has arrived this year.

And while we wait for Obama to surprise us, every year is a challenge for me as I try to determine how to commemorate this tragedy that impacted my family. Some years I attend the noon rally in Times Square which takes place on the Sunday closest to April 24 (this year Sun. April 26) and other years I stay home and read something which teaches me about an aspect of the topic I didn’t know about previously. This year, I have chosen to remember through photography, or at least browsing as many images as possible about the tragedy that befell 1.5 million Ottoman Armenians. Looking at images from a bygone era can be remarkable and enlightening–but if you’re reading this blog you probably already know that. Thankfully one of the best resources is online and I am proud to say that I helped put it there.

Last year, AGBU, an international Armenian non-profit I work for, launched a Flickr page which has developed into a living breathing resource of contemporary and archival photos, including, most significantly, the archive of the AGBU Nubarian Library in Paris.

2487496310_129befbf34A photo of an Armenian Genocide refugee, AGBU Archives

Established in 1928, the Nubarian Library is a repository of about 10,000 photographs (not to mention manuscripts, books, and other documents). While only a fraction of those are related to the Armenian Genocide, what makes the images particularly important is that few images from the catastrophe actually exist.

Unlike the Holocaust of World War II, the Armenian Genocide left a very small photographic footprint. The Ottoman Empire was a technologically underdeveloped region and photography was not as common as it was decades later. The few images that survive were often taken by Western missionaries, diplomats, humanitarians or travelers. AGBU’s collection is also unique in that many of the images were taken by Armenians themselves.

For those who may be interested, in addition to the AGBU archive there is a famous archive of images by Armin T. Wegner in Germany. Wegner, it should be noted, after witnessing the horror that befell Armenians went on to be the only writer in Nazi Germany ever to publicly protest the persecution of the Jews via an open letter to Adolf Hitler in 1933.

One of the collections in the AGBU archive that fascinates me the most is the YPGNY Gerard Archive which contains hundreds of images taken by an American nurse who served with the American Committee for Relief in the Near East and worked directly with Armenian Genocide refugees.

2422148328_fa553e25f9A page from Ellen Mary Gerard’s personal photo album depicting her work helping Armenian Genocide refugees in Lebanon & Syria

Her stash of photos were purchased at the beginning of our own century from a military antique shop in Glendale, California by the AGBU Young Professionals of Greater New York (I was a board member of the committee at the time).

Among the chilling images are snippets of stories that cast a light on this dark chapter in history. The one that continues to touch me deeply is the tale of the “desert boy” [pictured below], who we only learn about through notes scribbled on the back of two of the photographs:

This child was found in the desert – He had lived on roots + herbs + grass for nearly two years. Was like a little wild animal when found. He was treated by M[Mr?].E.R. + survived.

To understand the Armenian Genocide all you really need to do is to look at his eyes, they seem to say it all.

The “Desert Boy” from the YPGNY Ellen Mary Gerard Archive, AGBU Archives

To view the small set of the “Desert Boy” click here.

Btw, feel free to explore AGBU Flick archive yourself.

15 responses to “Obama, the Armenian Genocide & the Photographic Record”

  1. […] Vartanian has a stirring post with photographs from the Armenian […]

  2. onno alixanian Avatar
    onno alixanian

    Congratulations Hrag for an excellent article …and great research..

  3. Joanne Mattera Art Blog Avatar

    Thanks for this important post. The information is infuriating, enlightening and heartbreaking.

  4. A&D Avatar

    I cant believe that obama didn’t keep his promise. I mean you cant be surprised because he’s a young unexperienced man, who could blame him, obama yes with lover case, is like a little kid the only reason he promised that he’ll recognize Armenian genocide is to win the election, to gain armenian votes. We all have been fooled obama is a LIER!!!

  5. Linda Avatar

    Yes, he lied. He lied to get our votes. He just doesn’t get it.

  6. hv Avatar

    To be fair he used the term “Meds Yeghern” which is the Armenian terms for the Armenian Genocide. He may not have used the term we were waiting for but he did take one step closer to realizing what we are hoping for.

    The whole White House statement is here.

  7. Hovic Avatar

    ??? ????? ?????? ??? ???????? Armenian Genocide!!!
    Armenian Genocide = ???????? ?????????????? ??? ?????? ?????????????? ….. ?????!!!

  8. Hovic Avatar

    Oh, sorry remove my comment, I see your site doesn’t support unicode Armenian letters which is a standard on internet.

  9. Hrag Avatar

    Hi Hovic, I’ll install it. You’re the first to comment in Armenian so perhaps it’s something I should add.

  10. Marco Avatar

    Obama did well. Cuz as everyone knows well that so called armenian genocide is just a political campaign.

  11. hv Avatar

    Marco, your comment is very offensive and not to mention delusional.

  12. C yagjian Avatar
    C yagjian

    what Obama did was cowardly, there is no other appropriate adjective. Thank you for posting these photos, i stumbled upon your blog accidentally. This year on the 24th i had a small gathering with friends and we watched a documentary, i left feeling like i hadn’t learned much . i think despite how much discussion i’ve had about the genocide i have really avoided looking it straight in the eyes, the photos are so painful. this picture of the woman tears me to pieces, she reminds me why recognition is so important for us. maybe obama should spend some time staring at this photograph.

  13. Sylva Portoian Avatar

    The stories from my clinic on Armenian genocide
    The Al Shammari tribe in north of Iraq saved many dying children. One of
    them was found in river Khabour, so they named him Khabour.* They describe
    him as a blonde-haired person with blue eyes. His grandchildren say he looked
    different from our granduncles. He married from the tribe.
    There are many stories that people are still narrating from the Al Anazi and
    the Al Dhufayri tribes. They saved Armenian children in the Middle East, the
    Gulf, and Arabia, brought them up to become part of their families. They say
    they are proud to have Armenian origin. To understand the culture of Arabs and
    their dignity, they called the girls Merriam, which means Mary, as they were
    Christian and they believe in Merriam being mentioned in Qur’an; mother of
    Essa (Jesus). It was easier for them than Armenian names, which is difficult
    to pronounce and write. The name Merriam is heartily and holy in use among
    Muslim Arabs and Iranians, as frequent as Mary among Christians.
    The story achieved after natural personal observation:
    In spring of 1992, a Bedouin old woman brought her grandson to me, her face
    was covered as usual. Her petite white hands were holding her grandson in
    a delicate and artistic way that I was interested to see her face. She became
    friendly with me and, after detailed conversation, said my father was an
    Armenian orphan from the genocide, brought up by a Syrian family, and later
    married their daughter, who was my mother. She said at the end, “I am short
    like my father and have the same personality. He was a kind and intelligent
    man.” I do regret I did not collect more information; I never thought one day
    that I would be able write a book on genocide. I knew so much that I thought
    everyone knows about our untreatable pain.
    If I can say, almost all people living in the Middle East, Iran, Egypt, and
    Arabia know about the genocide, even the recent generation, but in Europe
    and USA, only among some groups.ill today I hear stories from the desert

  14. hv Avatar

    I am closing comments on this post. Thanks everyone.

Latest Posts

A Historic Year of Protests
This past year saw a huge groundswell of support for protests, most notably for Black Lives Matter. Protests for Palestine, Artsakh, and Pride were also some of the other campaigns …
The T**** Presidential Library
(2021) My only question is if hardcore MAGA supporters would hurl themselves into the hole at a certain age, like something out of Logan's Run (1976), as a sign of …
My First Therapist
I took this photograph while leaving my first therapist's office. It was my last appointment. I went to her for 11 years. The first stretch lasted six years, then I …